Nora Reid believes scientific laws control everything, even love. With her grandparents’epic first kiss story cemented in her brain, Nora develops a hypothesis she’s determined to prove:for each person in the world, there is exactly one other person, and at first kiss, they’ll experience an immediate and intense reaction.
But after four years of zero-reaction kisses, she comes up with a new theory: maybe that pesky crush on her stunningly hot best friend Eli Costas is skewing her results.
She needs to get rid of him, and fast.
Eli Costas is an injury-prone lacrosse star with a problem—the one chance he had at winning over the girl next door resulted in the most epically sucktastic first kiss ever. And now she’s…trying to get rid of him? Hell no. It’s time to disprove her theory and show her exactly what she’s missing.
Disclaimer: This book contains a stunningly hot lacrosse player who isn’t above playing dirty to win over the stubborn girl-next-door of his dreams.
3.5 stars — I received a free copy through NetGalley in exchange for an honest and unbiased review/opinion.
Well that was an up and down ride!! It started off really strong, I absolutely adored the author’s voice in this one. There was a bit of sassiness and snark that was delightful. I spent time both loving and hating BOTH characters, but in this case (unlike my previous read), I’m happy to say they redeemed themselves and showed those two words I love in characters: GROWTH AND CHANGE!
Nora was an intriguing, if frustrating, heroine! It’s funny, b/c at first I thought she was going to be really snarky, but that didn’t really last. I felt for the damage she sustained from her divorced parents, and their rather toxic relationship. I also liked that it wasn’t something we saw that much (as we never met the father), but you could see the damage in so many subtle little ways…not the least of which was her ridiculous hypothesis. As a reader, I found it really hard to watch her hang onto her theory with such a tightfisted grip. But I guess she really wanted to believe she could avoid her mother’s mistake. I sometimes think the smartest people can just not see the most obvious things sometimes. Hence the frustrating part of Nora. She also had a bit of high school damage. By holding on to this theory, and testing it out on all the boys, she’d kind of alienated herself from many of her fellow students…and my heart broke for her trying to navigate that.
Eli was just as intriguing, and honest to god, just as frustrating…but in a completely different way. I had completely different expectations for this story, and particularly for Eli. I honestly thought he was always in love with her, and figured this was his chance. But it’s not quite that. Quite frankly, that confused and frustrated me. If he just knew he loved her and was finally making his move, I’d have been immediately on board (I love those stories). But he was so confusing!! And confused! He wanted to get another chance with Nora and he wanted to prove her hypothesis wrong using himself as an example, but he kept initially framing it as though that was all he wanted…like for her own good, so she wouldn’t be lonely. But dude, that’s kind of dickish. And so I was confused how that was going to go. And worried. But I’ll get back to that in a moment. I was also startled by his personality and attitude sometimes. I expected a more laidback sweet guy, and he wasn’t quite that. Honestly, he actually felt like a really realistic depiction of a teenage guy. He had all this anger bottled up sometimes…which from what I understand from my husband is a common teenage boy problem, testosterone and all. He didn’t always appreciate his parents. He wasn’t the most tactful with Nora. It was odd. And yet I still liked him. He still had these great moments. And I guess I kind of liked that he was a bit oblivious to his own feelings, at least it was different.
I was honestly REALLY concerned when I got to what I thought was the climax. Eli behaved VERY BADLY. Like, a total jerky douchebag. Like, yelling and sneering. I was ready to wash my hands of the story, I didn’t think it could turn around. But there was more story left than I had anticipated. And you know what? To my GREAT surprise, I actually appreciated how the story played out afterwards. I’m still not super impressed with how Eli handled that particular moment, but I actually felt like I saw him go through all the emotions after that. I saw him grow up a bit. I saw him make realizations. And Nora too! I was freaking ecstatic with the final scene! Like it was actually everything I was wanting! I was shocked! I’m not saying everyone will be happy with it…just like I’m not saying everyone will have as big a problem with the climax. But it worked for ME.
As an aside, can I say that I really liked a lot of the secondary characters?? The parents were actually pretty great. Flawed, but great. Eli’s friend, Koviak, was cooler than I was expecting… And even Tex was an OK character. Abby was meh though. BUT the secondary character star for me was Eli’s little brother (who is on the autism spectrum). Both Eli and Nora showed their best selves with Ari. And he was just kind of delightful.
So yeah. I thought this was going to be a 3 star. But I’m even rounding up! Just shows how important a great ending is.